Bakery accidentally makes 'My Little Tony' cake for birthday

All a 9-year-old little girl wanted was to see magical, colorful ponies on her birthday cake: she got a dead Italian singer instead.

The embarrassing mistake came from a pastry shop in Gangi, Sicily when they were asked to make a 'My Little Pony'-themed birthday cake for the girl's birthday party. According to the

, the staff mistakenly heard 'My Little Tony.' When the family came to get the cake, it featured a picture of a bouffant-haired former singer named '

' Ciacci in a white jacket.

Ciacci was the equivalent of Elvis in the late 1950s and early 1960s in Italy and Great Britain. He died in 2013 at the age of 72.

Since the girl had never heard of 'Little Tony,' the bakery has been ordered by the Italian Consumer Association to pay for the girl's entire party.